1. Motivation and Philosophy:
- American Redoubt: Driven by conservative political views, survivalism, and preparation for societal collapse.
- Village Living: Focused on community building, sustainability, and optimizing for human flourishing through shared resources and efforts.
2. Political Orientation:
- American Redoubt: Strongly conservative and libertarian.
- Village Living: Politically neutral, emphasizing community values over specific political ideologies.
3. Economic Model:
- American Redoubt: Emphasizes individual self-reliance and traditional free-market economics.
- Village Living: Proposes a hybrid model with shared resources, communal labor, and reduced emphasis on individual profit.
4. Social Structure:
- American Redoubt: Attracts like-minded individuals but doesn't necessarily emphasize communal living.
- Village Living: Deeply integrated communal structure with shared responsibilities and resources.
5. Technology and Innovation:
- American Redoubt: Often skeptical of modern technology, focusing on traditional skills.
- Village Living: Embraces technology for efficiency, including AI for community management and task allocation.
6. Openness and Diversity:
- American Redoubt: Tends to attract a homogeneous group with similar political and religious views.
- Village Living: Potentially more open to diversity, focusing on shared values of community and sustainability.
7. Resource Management:
- American Redoubt: Emphasis on individual stockpiling and personal preparedness.
- Village Living: Centralized resource management with a focus on efficiency and equitable distribution.
8. Work and Labor:
- American Redoubt: Traditional job roles and economic structures.
- Village Living: Reimagined work structure with communal time allocation and task-based contributions.
9. Governance:
- American Redoubt: Minimal governance, emphasis on individual rights.
- Village Living: Participatory governance with detailed bylaws and community-driven decision making.
10. Long-term Vision:
- American Redoubt: Preparing for potential societal breakdown or conflict.
- Village Living: Creating a sustainable, fulfilling lifestyle that could serve as a model for broader societal change.